Lesson 15: Assessing Management

Value investing 101

You can analyze a company thoroughly, know the numbers down to the last decimal, and find what seems to be an attractive valuation… but if the management is no good, you're still at serious risk of disappointment.

The importance of management quality is often underestimated. And that’s understandable: it’s harder to measure than things like profit growth or return on equity. Still, it’s a crucial part of fundamental analysis, especially for long-term investors. As a shareholder, you’re a part-owner of the business, and you only want to partner with people you trust and respect.

Benjamin Graham put it well:
“Shareholding theoretically gives control over the company. In practice, shareholders behave like passive spectators.”

There are three central reasons why management is critically important:

1. Strategy and vision set the direction of the ship - Without a clear course, there's no sustainable growth.

2. Capital allocation determines how efficiently a company grows - What do they do with profits? Reinvest? Pay dividends? Make acquisitions? Reduce debt?

3. Culture and integrity shape the durability of success - Company culture comes from the top. Good leadership promotes transparency, accountability, and long-term thinking.

As Warren Buffett says:
“When a management with a reputation for brilliance tackles a business with poor economic characteristics, it’s the business that usually keeps its reputation.”

In other words, good management doesn’t guarantee success, but bad management almost always guarantees trouble.

Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger have clear criteria for evaluating corporate leaders: competence, integrity, and passion. If even one is missing, it’s a dealbreaker.

Always ask yourself:

• Would I willingly trust these people with my money if there were no stock price involved?

• Do I believe they work for me as a shareholder, or just for themselves?

If the answer is unclear, it’s best to look elsewhere.

---

12 Key Questions to Assess Management

These 12 practical questions help you analyze management quality. A company doesn’t need a perfect score, but the more boxes you can tick, the more confidence you can have.

1. Has the company performed well over time under this management?
   Don’t focus on one good year; look at 5 to 10 years of revenue growth, earnings per share, free cash flow, and ROE. Consistency matters more than growth speed.

2. What does the balance sheet look like?
   Good managers keep debt under control, especially in cyclical sectors. Avoid companies that constantly refinance or take unnecessary risks.

3. How wisely is capital allocated?
   Is free cash flow reinvested in profitable projects, or wasted on acquisitions and expensive perks? Are you getting value as a shareholder?

4. How long has management been in charge?
   A long track record often signals stability and vision. Also, check for turnover in key executive roles, frequent changes are rarely a good sign.

5. How are executives compensated?
   Bonuses tied to short-term profit or revenue are risky. Prefer compensation linked to ROIC, FCF, or per-share growth. The best leaders invest their own money in the company.

6. Are they increasing or reducing their own stake?
   Are they building up share ownership, or selling off as soon as their options vest? Insider buys signal confidence. Frequent insider selling is a red flag.

7. Do they issue quarterly forecasts?
   A focus on quarterly targets often signals short-term thinking. Companies with long-term vision usually avoid guidance and focus on building lasting value.

8. How well do they manage costs?
   Are they careful with shareholder capital, or wasting it on prestige projects, fancy offices, or bloated overhead? Simple communication and cost-awareness are good signs.

9. How do they handle bad news?
   Are they honest, or do they sweep problems under the rug? Transparency and accountability are key traits of trustworthy leadership.

10. Do they have a unique strategy, or just follow the herd?
    Do they copy competitors, or stick to their own path? Companies that roll out a “new plan” every quarter often lack a long-term vision.

11. How clear is their communication?
    Read the shareholder letters. Do you understand what they’re saying, or do they drown you in vague jargon and buzzwords? Clarity = trust.

12. Are they genuine, or just managing their image?
    A CEO constantly on TV or social media, putting ego before shareholders, is not a sustainable leader. Character matters more than charisma.

---

What Are Red Flags?

Here are some warning signs you shouldn’t ignore:

🚩 Management with no meaningful share ownership
🚩 Aggressive accounting with lots of “one-time adjustments”
🚩 Acquisitions unrelated to the core business
🚩 Huge compensation without performance links
🚩 Obsessive focus on revenue growth at the expense of margins or capital returns
🚩 Consistent shareholder dilution
🚩 No accountability for mistakes or poor results

---

Where to Find This Information

You won’t find answers to these questions in a single Excel sheet. But with some effort, you can uncover everything you need:

• Annual reports – especially letters to shareholders

• Earnings calls and interviews – listen for tone, consistency, openness

• Shareholder presentations and ownership structures

• News articles, sector analyses, podcasts, and employee reviews

Use your common sense. You’ll often spot good management more easily by what they don’t say than by what they do.

So don’t just learn how a business works, learn who’s running it, and why they do what they do.

The numbers tell you what has happened. The management tells you what might happen next.